Man arrested for carjacking and robbery charges acquitted at trial in San Francisco County Superior Court

5 mins read

San Francisco County Superior Court acquitted 28 12 months outdated Valentine Sua final week on each carjacking and robbery counts which he was charged with final May in San Mateo, California involving an electrical automobile confusion. 

On May 2, 2020 shortly after 5pm, San Francisco police arrested Sua in a leisure automobile close to a put up workplace on South Delaware Street, three quarters of a mile from the crash scene. Sua who was visiting household and pals in Sunnydale, San Francisco skilled automobile bother on his method and tried to flag a number of folks to assist him jumpstart his automobile, in line with a report by Dylan Ferguson revealed in The Davis Vanguard. 

According to proof discovered, a person in Prius had been seen providing his assist. The Toyota Prius is a full hybrid electrical vehicle first manufactured by Toyota in 1997 and has a really quiet equipment and Sua was reportedly confused by its quiet begin and assumed that the person had not turned on the automobile. 

Ferguson reported that Sua “reached into the Prius to start it and asked for the key” to jumpstart his automobile however the 36 12 months outdated man who had immigrated from China a 12 months in the past didn’t perceive what Sua was asking. In an account given by the person to the San Francisco police, he was instructed by the “suspect” to get out of the automobile and thought that he was being carjacked. In utter confusion and panic, the person ran away. 

Sua additionally panicked and fled the scene utilizing the Toyota Prius and headed South on U.S. Highway 101 close to the state Highway 92 interchange when the automobile “veered out of control and flipped, landing in the traffic lanes” stated San Mateo police officer Michael Haobsh. Sua then ran away from the crash scene injured down sixteenth Avenue west to South Delaware road the place he was arrested by the police. 

The jury’s purpose for Sua’s acquittal was that “Sua did not “use force or fear” with the intent of stealing a automobile that belonged to a person who had stopped to assist him soar begin his personal automobile.”

Deputy Public Defender Eric Fleischaker who represented Sua in court docket famous that the flight response was largely out of worry of the police. “Mr. Sua’s panicked flight response was based on his previous interactions with police while growing up in Sunnydale where he has always felt like the police assume he’s guilty,” Fleischaker stated. 

To present cultural perception to Sua’s response, the protection referred to as upon Larry Jones Jr., a social employee who additionally grew up in Sunnydale public housing. In an announcement by Valerie Ibarra from the SF Public Defender’s workplace, Jones acknowledged that there’s “nearly constant and often negative police presence in the few square blocks of Sunnydale, which is monitored at all times by 59 surveillance cameras.”

The established surveillance cameras in the realm supplied key proof on the case proving that Sua had certainly been making an attempt to leap begin his automobile all day and had been seen flagging folks right down to ask for assist. Fleischaker proceeded to state that this proves that “Mr. Sua was intending to start his own car, not to steal someone else’s.”

Additionally, Fleischaker additionally acknowledged that regardless of system involvement throughout Sua’s youthful years, he had been in a position to get his life again on monitor with a job, promotion, and a household and an incident like that may price him which explains his response to flee. 

Thomas Lake

Resident tech nerd for the SF Times.

Delivered weekly to your inbox📰

Stay connected with the heart of the Bay Area! Subscribe to the SF Times Friday Paper for your weekly dose of local news, events, business updates, and more from San Francisco and surrounding areas. Don't miss out on what's happening in your city.


We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

You have Successfully Subscribed!